My Best Meals Happen When I Stop Trying

Mushrooms on toast

By Chef Alexis Hernandez

The Kind of Dinner That Happens After Everything Else

Some of my best meals started with zero expectations.

No plan. No pressure. No one to impress — not even myself.

I do not mean the dinners I planned for guests or the ones I thought might turn into something worth remembering. I mean the nights when I got home too tired to perform and cooked anyway.

That kind of cooking happened a lot when I lived in Georgia.

I was working in the kitchen all day then, sometimes starting early, sometimes getting home late, sometimes coming straight in from the airport feeling like my whole body still belonged to work. If my other half was traveling and I was home alone, dinner got even simpler. I was not about to come home from a full day in a professional kitchen and start dirtying half the house just to prove I could.

That was never the mood.


Sauteed mushrooms


The Georgia Tuesday I Still Remember

One night I came home alone after a long day and opened the refrigerator to what looked like the remains of other intentions.

Mushrooms. Stale bread. A half bar of cream cheese wrapped in plastic. Chives. A little cream. Some leftover pieces of cheese. Boar’s Head ham. Olives. Half a can of tomato juice. A bag of parsley that probably needed to be used.

Not enough to make a plan out of. Just enough to make dinner.

So I did what I always do when I am too tired to overthink things. I started with what made sense.

I toasted the bread.

I sautéed the mushrooms with thyme and Worcestershire. Added cream. Let it reduce until it turned into something rich enough to feel like more than mushrooms on toast. Then I poured it over the bread, finished it with chopped chives, and called it dinner.

Before I ate, I poured myself a glass of gin to unwind. Then later I poured a glass of unoaked Chardonnay and sat down with that plate like it was exactly what I had meant to make all along.

That is the thing about relaxed cooking. Sometimes it starts with almost nothing and still manages to feel complete.


Toast in a toaster


What Happens When I Stop Performing

I think I cook better when I stop trying so hard to look like someone who is cooking well.

When I relax, I pay attention.

I notice when the mushrooms stop giving off water and finally start taking color. I notice when cream has reduced enough to coat instead of puddle. I notice when something needs acid at the end — balsamic if that is what I have, lemon or lime if there is one rolling around in the drawer.

That is usually how I cook when I am not performing. I taste. I adjust. I reach for what makes sense.

Relaxed cooking is not lazy cooking. It is just less self-conscious.


The Mistakes That Matter Less Than You Think

I still make mistakes.

One time I made a chicken and somehow never seasoned it with salt. It had onion powder on it, which yes, I use, and people should calm down about that and try it sometime. I had a sauce that went over it, and I noticed right away the chicken itself had missed something.

Nobody else said a word.

Maybe they were being nice. Maybe they eat unseasoned food at home every day and mine still had a little more life than what they were used to. But that dinner stayed with me because I remember how loud the mistake felt in my own head compared to how little it seemed to matter once the meal was actually on the table.

That is part of what relaxed cooking taught me too. Sometimes the pressure is bigger than the problem.

Sauteed Mushrooms

What Counts as Dinner

I learned that on quieter nights too.

One night I had saltine crackers, deli ham, cheese, and a leftover glass of Malbec from the day before. I remember thinking this would never pass for dinner party food.

It was really damn good.

That meal stayed with me for the same reason the mushroom toast did. It reminded me that dinner does not have to audition for anything. It does not have to be plated for applause or built around a story you can tell other people later.

Sometimes crackers and ham are enough.

And if crackers and ham can be dinner, then stale bread, mushrooms, and a little cream certainly can too.


Why It Works

Relaxed cooking makes better meals because I am not trying to prove anything.

I am not chasing perfect timing or trying to turn the kitchen into a performance. I am just cooking with what is there, using what I know, and letting the food tell me where it wants to go.

That is usually when I remember the part of cooking I actually love.

Not the showing off.

Not the pressure.

Just the quiet little act of making something good out of what the day left behind.

And maybe that is what I learned from all those quiet dinners.

Not every meal needs ambition to be worth remembering. Sometimes it is mushrooms over stale bread. Sometimes it is crackers, ham, cheese, and a glass of yesterday’s wine.

And maybe that is the point.

Dinner does not always need to rise to the occasion.

Sometimes it just needs to meet you where you are.