Mushroom Salad, Steak Frites, and Nothing to Prove

Salad with tomatoes

By Chef Alexis Hernandez

Maria knew first

My best friend Maria once invited me over to her place in Atlanta.

It was her second home while she worked on shows there — a little base camp between cities.

Her table was tiny, pushed up against bay windows that looked out over the shared garden of the neighboring building.

  Just a small table and late light.

We were talking and laughing, and at some point she asked, “You hungry? Want me to make something?”

I said yes and that was it.

She didn’t plan a lunch or a menu.

She made a salad and tore some baguette into pieces.

A dressing that was basically lemon juice, olive oil, salt, and pepper.

I did not hover over the cutting board to study every move.

I just watched her move through the living room, like feeding people was the most natural thing in the world.

We sat at that little table in the window.

The salad was bright and clean.

The bread caught what the leaves could not hold.

I remember feeling good about my life sitting there with my old high school friend and that simple bowl of greens.

I did not think, this is luxury. After all these years, I still remember that moment.


Parisian menu on a chalkboard


A chalkboard in Paris

Years before Maria’s table, I had seen the same thing written in chalk.

We arrived late to a restaurant in Paris, the kind of late where the kitchen is getting ready to close.

The menu was on a chalkboard. Only a few dishes were left.

A mushroom salad. Steak frites. A soup.

We ordered what they still had because that was the deal.

The mushroom salad and the steak frites arrived.

Simple.

Precise.

No swagger.

The salad was just champignons de Paris — common white button mushrooms sliced thin and served raw.

They had been sitting in a sharp vinaigrette, then tossed with a spoonful of crème fraîche, chives, and parsley.

They tasted fresh and a little meaty at the same time, like they had grown a backbone in the bowl.

Nothing about it needed explaining. It was the kind of thing you eat and think, If this is all dinner is, I am still happy.

The steak frites were exactly what you are picturing. Hot. Salty.

Fries that actually arrived crisp. A steak cooked like someone in the kitchen that still felt like cooking, even at the end of service.

There were no tests between me and that food. The plates were not trying to prove anything.

I was not trying to prove I was the right kind of diner.

We met in the middle.

We liked each other.

I loved that mushroom salad so much I put a version of it on my own restaurant menu later.

It ran as a special for weeks.

People came back for it.

They did not always know why.

They just knew it felt good.


Steak Frites


What I want at the table now

I think about those two meals more than I think about some much fancier ones.

A salad and torn baguette at Maria’s tiny table.

Mushrooms and steak frites under a fading chalkboard menu.

Neither one was dressed up in obvious expense. Both of them felt rich.

I am less interested in a table that wants credit for trying hard.

I want a meal that lets people exhale.

One good cheese instead of five that all taste alike.

Bread that actually tastes like something.

Salt you can really taste.

Acid that does its job. A main ingredient treated with respect instead of fear.

Nothing piled for effect and nothing begging to be admired.

Just a plate that arrives ready.

You know the kind of dinner where you hesitate on the last piece of bread because it feels like someone is keeping score.

The plates look like sculpture and you leave a little hungry and not sure it was your fault.

That is not what I want anymore. I am finding that what I want is more simple now.

Just a table where nobody has to work that hard to enjoy themselves.